Judging vs Being Judgmental
Google Image
“Who am I to judge?”
This must be Pope Francis’ most famous quote.
It came from a press conference on an airplane in 2013 when Francis was asked
about gays in the church. The phrase was considered revolutionary for a pope
and launched a controversy about how the church should respond to
homosexuality.
It brought praise from some; condemnation from
others. Some critics said it confused people. Others said it appeared to place
the pope on the side of moral relativism – the term used to describe denial of the
existence of objective morality, holding instead that there is “your right and
wrong and my right and wrong.”
Indeed, the pope’s words were a shock for the Catholics
who believe judging is exactly what a pope is supposed to do.
Clear?
But isn’t the gospel pretty clear on the
subject?
“Judge not and you will not be judged,” Jesus
is quoted as saying in Mathew’s gospel. Does
that apply to popes? And he continued in an even more powerful way, saying,
“Why do you see the speck in your brother’s eye but don’t notice the log that’s
in your eye?”
But didn’t Jesus himself do a lot of judging?
Again according to Mathew’s gospel, Jesus said the scribes and Pharisees were
like “whitewashed tombs, which outwardly appear beautiful but within are full
of dead men’s bones….” In Luke’s gospel, Jesus calls Herod Antipas, who ruled
Galilee and was the son of the Herod the Great who was in power when Jesus was
born, a “fox.”
Commentators don’t seem to agree on what Jesus
meant. Foxes had, and still have, a reputation for being sly or cunning, and
this Herod was evidently hoping to scare Jesus into abandoning his preaching in
Herod’s territory. But foxes, according to some scholars, were also considered
to be unclean animals according to Jewish tradition.Google Image
The point here is that Jesus seemed to be
judging the scribes and Pharisees and Herod Antipas. Ok, so traditional
Christian theology recognizes Jesus as God and judging is what God does.
But to take it a bit further, shouldn’t we
judge public figures to determine whether they deserve our support? And don’t
we rightly judge people, at least to ourselves, on a daily basis to determine
whether we want, or should, deal with them in business or some other capacity?
I believe distinctions are to be made, at least
for people searching for God. Seems to me the kind of judging we should NOT do
is the kind that is reserved for God. “Is this person, despite his or her
faults, redeemable?” “Is he or she accepted by God?” None of us are capable or
such judgments.
Judging by Appearances
One of the problems for humans who attempt to
judge is that we invariably judge by appearances, a trait also critiqued in the
Bible, like
in the first book of Samuel. “…For the Lord
sees not as man sees; man looks on the outward appearance but the Lord looks at
the heart.”
Today, and I suspect like the people in Jesus’
day, we judge people by whether they’re overweight; whether they have tattoos;
whether they wear fashionable or expensive clothes or shoes; whether they go to
our church or are members of our political party; whether they’re too old or
too young; or
by the color of their skin or their accent.
Maybe people searching for God, who should
strive to be God-like, should remember that we can’t look into another’s heart
so we shouldn’t try. The phrase, “Hate the sin but love the sinner” sums up the
church’s traditional view on judging and I believe it’s a good rule of thumb.
Comments
Post a Comment